Deck Tiering System On XDA?

I have a suggestion on how to make the XDA meta more balanced and fun - that idea is to add different tiers for different deck. I haven't decided what the tiers will be named or how many there will be or what decks will be placed in which tier. All I currently know, though, is that it would be cool if we had certain tiers for whenever a XDA-related duel occurs. For example: Let's say that PePe and Kozmo are tier 1, and that Satellarknights and Burning Abyss are tier 2. Then PePe and Kozmo would be able to duel each other, but not, say, PePe and Satellarknights, because they are in different tiers.

To summarize, decks should be placed into tiers based on how good they are, and decks within tiers can only duel each other. This could be used for Arena Duels, Tournaments and other possible future XDA activities involving dueling.

What do you all think of this idea?

I think that is a great ideal when in a tourney cuz it will come down to skill and luck instead of the power of the theirs cards.

I mean on just XDA.

im with you on that one Nyataria

I'm with Nyataria on this one. If this happened in a tournament, there is such abnormalities such as decks that just aren't in the tier list at ALL, and if someone was forced to use a deck in a tier that they haven't played that would give a significant advantage to whoever chose the tier as they obviously know more about the deck. It would also create arguments between what deck was where, and make people create decks and learn decks just for the sake of dueling 1 person. I feel like tournaments that only focused around a single tier would be good, like a tier 1 tournament where only tier 1 decks could be used so if you have knowledge of the tier 1 decks you can sign up if you want, but not this strange tier system.

you kind of need one for tournaments but that depends on who organizes it. it is only good for daily usage if your testing system is based on a tier list.